InternetException

Old dependable technology

· 1012 words · ~5 min read · in general

#reliability #llm #slop

I was enjoying the end of this year’s summer. Weather was really nice, for Poland and for September - 20 degrees C.

It was quiet because my kids went inside for some dinner and a bath. Rare occasion for a parent of 3. And because of that rare moment being available I decided to linger a bit more myself.

Old dependable technology

I was watching the fire and thinking how warm it was and how predictable it is that it is warm.

I was also watching some movie on my phone and for some reason the Wifi signal disappeared. It got me thinking how those 2 things differ.

Old dependable technology

You sit by the fire. You enjoy its warmth. But on the other hand you know to not get too close. It is known. Everybody understands why, because everybody burnt himself at some point, usually in childhood. So you know that it is nice and warm, but also dangerous. You do not have to test it every time you see a new fire. You know that fire is hot. You know it is possible to get hurt and lose something or someone.

It has been like that always for thousands of years; people learned how to use it, how to avoid its dangers and finally how to harness it for their own good. What is a combustion engine if not fire locked in a metal box to harness its power?

There are other things like fire that we know how they work because we learnt observing our world and surroundings during childhood. Stones are hard and heavy. When you throw them someone might get hurt. Water flows. If you throw a stone in water it will sink. But if you tie a rope around a stone and throw it into the water you can make a buoy or it will anchor something to this place.

It is predictable.

It is dependable.

New unreliable technology

On the other hand I had a choppy wifi signal. It was working but not stable and it was a bit annoying. Kind of a property of all new/high technologies: it mostly works but often it does not. You probably know the meme “did you try to turn it off and on again?” - the easiest way to make new technology work again is to restart it - kind of make a new one to ensure a clean starting state. Imagine if you would have to do that to a fire every few hours: ‘put it out and then start it again to make sure it behaves’.

Have you tried turning it off and on again?

It is mostly caused by software. Restarting a router or a printer is mostly caused by software misbehaving. Of course there are other problems: network issues, wire issues, power issues that may cause hardware to be less reliable, that combined with buggy software will make it even less predictable.

And it is even worse with constant software changes: things get moved, ui gets redesigned, agreements change and features get taken away, a company can go bankrupt and you will lose access to your software or even hardware because it is always online, login only.

And with unpredictability comes annoyance. Imagine if we would live in a world when some stones from time to time started floating on water and you would have to hit them with a stick to force them to behave. If you would use them as an anchor and you would have to fetch your boat few hundreds meters down the river because of that? It would be maddening. You depend on those things to behave in a predictable manner. If something is not and it is not dangerous it causes annoyance.

Can we make this better with hardware and software? Most probably. We were able, as a species, to land people on the moon and get them back. There is just no incentive to do so. There is reliability and maintenance cost on the other hand. For example power lines: we could have double or even triple power lines going to some places. But this makes the cost higher. And even if you have more lines and they are in the same place, all of them will be cut by the same accident. And putting them apart makes the cost even bigger. So we do not.

On the other hand we have planes, that usually have double and triple circuits and spares for most important functionalities. It does not prevent us from fixing some problem with duct tape in them from time to time.

Military technology is also sometimes more reliable by making it sturdy and pricier. But for customer grade products we prefer for it to be cheap and we can work with less reliable hardware.

Even less reliable software

But software is even less reliable. So on top of unreliable hardware we slap some buggy software and we call it a day.

Will it be better with so called AI? Most probably not, as we get less reliable hardware in the last couple of dozens of years. When I was growing up I had the same fridge most of my childhood. Now, when I have been living about 9 years in my own home, I have my 3rd already.

It is caused by both: companies wanting cheaper manufacturing and customers wanting cheaper products, which is possible with automation and better manufacturing in masses.

The same will happen to software: cheaper manufacturing of software and mass production of software. Both will make it cheaper but at the same time less reliable.

If you thought that current software is not reliable, just wait for mass produced LLM slop. Imagine if you would have a total rewrite of your vacuum cleaner mobile app every two weeks and every time stuff randomly would be moved or would stop or start working. It will be even worse in terms of reliability.

And at times I am not sure if I will not prefer to sit by the fire and throw stones into the water.

Just to have some stability in my life.